I HATE Instant Snoring ‘Cures’ – they Do More Harm than Good [2019]

I HATE Instant Snoring ‘Cures’ – they Do More Harm than Good [2019]

by | Mar 18, 2019 | OTC, Sleep-Related Breathing Disorders, Snorer, undiagnosed | 3 comments

Rated 5/5 based on 16 customer reviews

It starts off like this:

Imagine, you have a snoring problem and like so many people, you search online for a ‘cure’, a quick fix – and in no time at all there it is:

Your instant snoring cure!

Sold to you with all sorts of promises, guarantees and ‘testimonials’ – etc. etc.

What could possibly go wrong? 

I HATE instant snoring ‘cures’ because they do more harm than good.

What annoys me about supposed instant ‘snoring cures’, aids, strips and goodness knows what gadgets, is that unscrupulous businesses are simply exploiting desperate snorers (and their families and partners) for profit, without giving a damn about the punter; the harm their ‘cures’ do and the delay the cause, in obtaining actual help.

Such businesses encourage the desperate to part with their cash by asking daft questions, such as:

‘Work out what kind of snorer you are’

Read self-diagnose to then sell them a supposed instant ‘snoring cure’ to ‘treat’ snoring.

The merit (or otherwise) of the supposed ‘cure’ is one thing, but:

The individual is unable to distinguish between anti-social, nuisance snoring and obstructive sleep apnoea

It is a SCAM and a dangerous one at that. Funnily enough they will have just the cure you need in stock!

That’s a surprise isn’t it…

Here’s an analogy

If you cannot see properly – do you guess what lenses you need and fit your own glasses?

No of course you don’t.

You get assessed, diagnosed and provided with the right ones.

Key points are:

1  Assessment
2  Diagnosis
3  Prescription treatment

In that order – by a Professional.

Snoring is no different.

It’s not a joke: 

In fact it could be very serious indeed.

So, if you’re thinking about a ‘cure’ then get signposted to the most appropriate professional to help you. 

Read on…

Let’s break your argument down

You’re the expert right?

Its your snoring after all – and your mouth, teeth and gums too. What would a Dentist know about teeth and gums?

Yes exactly:

A lot.

But Snoring? What do Dentists know about that?

Instant snoring cures are most commonly things you wear in your mouth. Some Dentists (see below) choose to develop a special interest in snoring or more correctly ‘sleep-related breathing disorders’ (SRBD) and they should be your first call when you’re thinking of a snoring cure.

Think about it 

You’re going to wear this thing in your mouth while you are ASLEEP and depend upon it to keep your throat open, so you can breathe and sleep at the same time (and pray it doesn’t break and you end up inhaling or swallowing it…)

Dunno about you but I like breathing… and not having bits of broken gadget in my lungs…

That’s apart from the impact your instant snoring cure WILL have on your teeth, your gums and jaw-joints…

Click for: Dentists with a special interest in sleep

The lesson here is to see someone who knows what they are doing (and hasn’t just been on a manufacturer’s half-day course)

Both snoring and sleep apnoea / apnea deserve proper assessment, diagnosis and treatment. Not muffling with a ‘quick fix’ cure or gadget.

You might have seen some blurb for instant snoring gumshields online, at the Pharmacy, Dentist, Doctors or perhaps read about them here and there.

They are all over the internet.

You might have even read our Free NHS England’s Information Standard accredited Guide about
“How to choose a ‘mouthpiece'” and perhaps thought: – 

“Yeah that’s obviously a sales pitch as its co-written by a Dentist… and Dentists just want to make money right – so they’re going to say that Dentist fitted mouthpieces are better!”

 

Well, you’d be wrong:

We don’t sell anti-snoring gadgets, potions, cures, sprays or aids…..!

Get signposted to the most appropriate professional to help you stop snoring
(hint: it’s free)

How to stop snoring: The definitive, step-by-step Guide

What’s your beef with instant stop snoring ‘cures?’

I particularly hate instant snoring cures worn in your mouth, as the balance of side-effects versus benefits, is generally not in your favour:

All anti-snoring mouthpieces have side-effects

This is true for both instant and professional fit/custom-made ones fitted by a dentist.

It is simply a risk/benefit analysis.

This means you may well suffer some irreversible harm – or – if you get lucky just waste your money

Let’s clear this up now:

Anti-snoring mouthpieces may also be described as splints, gumshields, mandibular repositioning devices, oral devices and appliances. Or combinations of these terms. You may see: MRD, MAS, MAD…

But this is not a post comparing the merits of Over-the-Counter versus Custom-Made Mandibular Advancement Devices.
This is.

You should be screened for sleep apnoea before using ANY ‘cure’

Assuming you are not keen on being exploited by the unscrupulous ‘quick fix’ gang selling ‘cures’ and snake oil, or are into hurting yourself… and you want to stop snoring – you should be screened for obstructive sleep apnoea symptoms first.

Snoring may be warning sign of Obstructive Sleep Apnoea/Apnea (OSA).

You need knowledge and criteria for choice (which is what Snorer.com is all about):

How you can tell if the sleep-trained dentist knows their stuff?

Some simple questions to ask:

  • Are they a member of a professional dental sleep organisation?
  • Ask them what training they have in sleep
  • Are they insured to provide anti-snoring mouthpieces?
  • Do they offer a range of custom-made anti-snoring mouthpieces?
  • Ask to see example mouthpieces (they should have at least 2 or 3 different designs)
  • Do they work with a local hospital sleep/ENT department?

The responsible sleep-trained Dentist doesn’t just ‘fit’ you with an anti-snoring mouthpiece and wave goodbye.

They are going to make sure that your snoring isn’t a sign of obstructive sleep apnoea (OSA)

And if they are concerned refer you for specialist investigation. The Dentist will assess you including examination of your teeth, gums and jaw joint, to ensure that they are healthy and are able to withstand the loads the anti-snoring mouthpiece will place upon them.

And to establish the situation now before you start using the mouthpiece (so change may be monitored) they will take x-rays of your teeth (or if fairly recent x-rays exist – request sight of them from your regular dentist).

They will establish that your nasal airway is satisfactory, they will assess the size of your tongue, soft palate and oral tissues. The list goes on and on. They will also keep what is known as ‘master casts’ (records of the position of your teeth). Oh and their training is recognised by their professional indemnity insurer.

They do this to ensure they don’t make a problem while trying to ‘cure’ your snoring

The ideal anti-snoring mouthpiece doesn’t exist

The ideal anti-snoring mouthpiece yet exist – but fear not. Getting close to perfect for you is something that the expert sleep-trained Dentist can help you with (it depends upon many things eg: how many teeth you have and where, whether you grind your teeth [bruxism] and how much you can protrude [push your jaw forwards] amongst other things).

The feature set below should help you have a more informed conversation:

  1. Cheap (or very durable and can be modified if you lose a tooth)
  2. Has good retention
  3. Is adjustable
  4. Isn’t bulky
  5. Comfort (as in you can use it)
  6. Has minimal side effects
  7. Is easy to keep clean

Point 1

Cheap – Click here to learn more

Point 2

Retention – Click here to learn more

Point 3

Adjustable – Click here to learn more

Point 4

Bulky – Click here to learn more

Point 5

Comfort – Click here to learn more

Point 6

Side Effects – Click here to learn more

Summary

Today, you have to be alert for scams online, in the Post, on the telephone, pretty much everywhere. (I even received a scam phone call while typing this).

Please use your head.

If it looks too good to be true – then don’t fall for it. Snoring may well be nothing more than a nuisance, but it could be obstructive sleep apnoea.

Self ‘diagnosing’ and ‘treating’ yourself with gimmicks and instant ‘cures’ is NOT a cost saving, it may well do you harm and mask a real problem that needs investigating and treating properly, regardless of whether it’s ‘just’ snoring or sleep apnoea.

Oh, and NO I am not a dentist.

Keep doing your homework by reading our impartial (we don’t sell them) comparison and review posts in the Related section below:

Created by Adrian Zacher. Page last updated 23rd March 2019

Related

Here are some more high quality Guides and reviews of snoring ‘cures’, aids and gadgets:

Found this useful?

Let me know:

What’s the best Anti-Snoring Device? Sleep-expert reviews top 13 criteria

What’s the best Anti-Snoring Device? Sleep-expert reviews top 13 criteria

by | Feb 17, 2019 | Gumshields for snoring, MADs (Mandibular Advancement Devices), Sleep-Related Breathing Disorders, Snoring | 0 comments

Rated 5/5 based on 16 customer reviews

What’s the best Anti-Snoring Device?

The best anti-snoring device is only prescribed after you’ve been screened for Obstructive Sleep Apnoea / Apnea (OSA).

The best one:

  • Stops your snoring
  • Costs you the least money (because it isn’t a false economy)
  • Creates the least side-effects (and helps you sleep and breathe at the same time)

So, if you’re wondering what’s the best anti-snoring device then read this independent (no advertisements or affiliate links!) sleep-industry expert review.

I’m a sleep-industry insider with a quarter of century of sleep medicine experience.

Adrian Zacher MBA

Snoring & Sleep Apnoea Care Navigator

Despite the lack of prior screening for sleep apnoea, anti-snoring devices (Mandibular Advancement Devices – MADs) or ‘gumshields for snoring’ are big business on the internet and in the pharmacy.

So, the challenge as a hasty snorer is:

How to choose one that actually works?!

Snoring aids and cures are increasingly popular as we recognise the impact poor sleep has upon our health, daytime functioning and work performance.

A Daily Mail article Ten Snoring Cures new window reviewed 10 ‘cures’ available in the UK. The journalist tried to stop his own snoring, with chin straps, pillows, sprays and ‘gumshields’, aka anti-snoring devices.

default gravatar

If you are looking for impartial advice about snoring from an expert in the field, the highly respected Adrian Zacher should be your go to. We applaud Adrian’s work, to raise awareness about the health implications of snoring, and the importance of custom-made devices for long-term success.

Lucie Ash Director Somnowell How to choose the best anti-snoring device September 7, 2018

He had little success and concluded his review by quoting a snoring expert, Consultant Respiratory Physician, Dr Tom McKay, from Edinburgh Royal Infirmary Sleep Centre, UK, as saying:

‘Sprays don’t have any great effect although nasal steroids have a small role if you’ve got nasal congestion. It can help to lose weight or avoid alcohol last thing at night or to sleep lying on your side. Various forms of gumshield are reasonably successful – maybe 50 or 60 per cent.’

So, its a reasonable question to ask….

Which Anti-Snoring Devices really work?

‘Gumshields for snoring’ could more accurately be described as mandibular advancement devices (MAD). They are also known as mandibular repositioning devices (MRD) or even sometimes mandibular advancement splints (MAS) !

But there are essentially just two categories:

  Over-the-Counter (OTC) ‘gumshields’
  Prescription, Custom-Made Dental Appliances

In this updated for 2019 review, I examine how both categories of anti-snoring device measure up against my Top 13 criteria for choice (see call out box) to determine which ones really work, and if they’re safe and effective.

And the best bit?

Each section concludes with my verdict and there’s a free bonus at the end!

  1. Clinical evidence it works
  2. Cost
  3. Comfort and bulk
  4. Impact on your teeth
  5. Are your jaw joints at risk?
  6. Retention (how well it stays in place)
  7. Ability to adjust protrusion
  8. Lifespan & cost-per-wear
  9. Control of mouth opening
  10. Lateral movement
  11. Tongue space invasion
  12. Easy to keep clean
  13. Side-effects
The Top 13 Criteria

To choose an MAD that works, and is safe & effective

CAUTION: Snoring may be a symptom of Obstructive Sleep Apnoea / Apnea (OSA)

Snoring may be a symptom of obstructive sleep apnoea/apnea (OSA).

Without first being screened for OSA your purchase of an OTC anti-snoring device, could harm you and if you snore because you have undiagnosed Obstructive Sleep Apnoea (OSA) the OTC gadget delays effective (and free on the NHS!) treatment that will prolong your healthy life.

Get signposted to the most appropriate professional (it’s free!)

The professional will screen you for OSA and decide if you’re ‘just’ a snorer or if your snoring needs investigating.

Your GP may be able to help you – but they may not know much about sleep apnoea as sleep is not part of core medical training. We provide expert written GP Guidelines to help.

In the UK, you can also find sleep-trained dentists who can screen you and recognise Obstructive Sleep Apnoea/Apnea (OSA) symptoms2, make custom anti-snoring devices for snorers, without a prior medical diagnosis, or if they suspect OSA refer you on for further investigation.

Clinical evidence (proof) that the MAD works

No. 1. Clinical evidence (proof) that the Anti-Snoring Device works

What does 'clinical evidence' actually mean?
Medical and dental experts review medical devices (clinical research) to establish if they work. Their research produces data and information which can be thought of as ‘proof’ that something does or does not work, and how well it works in certain circumstances. The evidence they create is also judged for quality.

Judging Anti-Snoring device (MAD) research quality

When selecting an anti-snoring device, it’s important to look at this clinical evidence. To judge the quality of a mandibular advancement device’s (MAD’s) clinical research evidence, you need to look past the headlines claiming “Clinical research– tick”.

What was the outcome of the research?!

Typical patient-centred measures of outcome

Measurement of what patients perceive as important effects from wearing an MAD typically include:

  • Partner reported snoring (derrr… a no-brainer!)
  • Daytime sleepiness
  • Quality of life
  • Adherence (long-term use)
  • Device preference
Gumshields for snoring
Gumshields or ‘Boil-and-Bite’ anti-snoring devices, have been clinically researched head-to-head against custom-made, prescription, adjustable anti-snoring devices and found to be lacking.

Our results suggest that the thermoplastic device cannot be recommended as a therapeutic option nor can it be used as a screening tool to find good candidates for mandibular advancement therapy.3

…patients overwhelmingly found the ready-made MRD difficult to tolerate…4

…96% of patients reported minor adverse events, which related predominantly to discomfort.4 [referring to a study by Dr. Tim Quinnell 5

Prescription, custom made MADs
Today, clinical research has established that custom made MADs are first-line therapy (the default first option) for snoring and mild obstructive sleep apnoea / apnea.

MAD research now focuses on:

Predictors of satisfactory outcome before purchase (who will benefit and why) and which type of custom made MAD is most effective for a given genotype (which MAD is best for YOU as opposed to a vanilla approach).

Expert’s verdict on clinical evidence for MADs
It is not enough to say that an MAD has been clinically researched. Such research may have proved the MAD didn’t work!

A positive outcome from clinical research can be thought of as a ‘guarantee’ of sorts.

My advice is to do your homework (grab the Bonus Mouthpiece Guide at the end) and be guided by a sleep-trained dentist. You can find one on via our Links new window page.

[Note: Below is an advanced topic about typical MAD research metrics. So, if you’re new to clinical evidence, feel free to skip this tip].

Typical Mandibular Advancement Device (MAD) research quality metrics include:
  • Total sample size (the ‘N’ or number of patients who used the device)
  • Could they tolerate it in their mouth (known as tolerance)
  • How many hours they used it for each night (known as compliance)
  • How many nights they used it for per week (part of the compliance metric)
  • Partner reporting of cessation of snoring
  • Perceived sleepiness before and after use
  • Before and during use blood oxygenation level
  • Before and during use AHI (apnoea hypopnea index – an index used to indicate the severity of sleep apnea. The number of apnea and hypopnea events per hour of sleep)
  • Whether a placebo was used with a control group
  • Whether patients crossed over to a different therapy / device
  • Whether the researchers and/or patients were ‘blind’ (who was aware which device was a placebo or an actual MAD?)
  • Has the research been published in a high profile and peer-reviewed journal? (This means other experts in the field judge it for quality)

No. 2. Anti-Snoring Device costs

OTC gumshields and ‘treatments’ might appear cheaper than custom-made, prescription appliances & dentist fees, BUT…

Are they a false economy?

Get signposted to the most appropriate professional to help you stop snoring
(hint: it’s free)

Get signposted to the right professional to stop snoring

Why use a dentist to get an Anti-Snoring Device (MAD)?

Financially, its tempting to cut out the dentist.

After all, a large part of the cost to you when purchasing a mandibular advancement device, is their clinical time.

The device fees vary, but what are you paying for?

Dentists know about teeth, gums and jaw-joints
That is what they do.

While Dentistry may initially seem expensive, the risks of not using an expert are considerable. Remember, you are relying on the anti-snoring device to hold open your airway while you sleep. Think carefully before you choose.

Some dentists are specially trained in snoring and sleep apnoea / apnea, known as sleep-related breathing disorders (SRBD) and work closely with medics. Dentists with a special interest in sleep, can help you find the correct balance of benefits versus side-effects.

If you have certain medical conditions, or grind your teeth, you might break an OTC ‘gumshield’ whilst you’re asleep. When you are asleep you cannot spit out pieces of a broken gadget. You could INHALE or SWALLOW pieces.

You can find sleep-trained dentists on our Links page. In the UK, look for the British Society of Dental Sleep Medicine.

Expert's verdict on whether to cut out the dentist
Don’t do it.

The terrifying thought of bits of MAD breaking off and being inhaled while you sleep, should surely make you realise you need to see a sleep-trained dentist and use a prescribed custom-made, adjustable anti-snoring appliance, made to quality standards.

In case you’re wondering, I’m not a dentist.

Anti-snoring device (mandibular advancement device - MAD)

Example of a custom-made Mandibular Advancement Device (MAD). Image above used with permission from SomnoMed.

Mandibular Advancement Device (MAD) made from metal

Example of a custom-made Mandibular Advancement Device (MAD). Image above used with permission from SomnoWell.

over the counter: anti-snoring devices

No. 3. Comfort and bulk of Anti-Snoring Devices (MAD)

An MAD that is so uncomfortable to wear, soon ends up being thrown across the bedroom or just left in the bathroom at bedtime…

Both the design and clinical expertise in how an anti-snoring device is supplied, directly impacts your likelihood of successfully wearing it (and therefore whether it stops your snoring) – particularly during the first two weeks of use.

This is when most people who aren’t going to get on with them, quit. It might seem obvious:

but if you don’t wear it – it doesn’t work.

OTC gumshields for snoring
Generally OTC gumshields for snoring are “one-size-fits-all”.

They have to be bulkier in size to adapt to your teeth than custom-made devices. This would mean it feels like you are squeezing a tennis ball into your mouth – Oh, and then you’re expected to sleep!

Custom-made MADs
A sleep-trained dentist will ensure that your MAD fits properly and doesn’t hurt.

They will also ensure you know how to put the device into your mouth and get it out again.

Expert's verdict on comfort and bulk
As a general rule, custom-made anti-snoring devices are less bulky than ‘gumshields’.

Due to the lack of accuracy of the ‘fit’ and one-size-fits-all approach of gumshields, they may be too large, too small or take up so much room in your mouth you can’t close your lips and you find yourself dribbling attractively!

Warning! Is this the best anti-snoring device for you? UK expert review

No. 4. Will an Anti-Snoring Device (MAD) damage my teeth and gums?

You wear these things in your mouth.
What impact will it have?

Gumshields for snoring
Its quite possible that a gumshield will place excessive load upon an individual tooth/teeth.

Over time your teeth will move. It will hurt.

And you will either stop wearing the mandibular advancement device and accept the financial loss (good luck trying to get a refund on a used product), or under duress from your partner and family, continue wearing it and risk losing the tooth or an expensive crown/cap/bridge.

Prescription, custom-made MADs
Prescription Mandibular Advancement Devices on the other hand, can be designed to avoid certain teeth if they are identified as at risk.

An expert sleep-trained dentist can help identify (and save that tooth) if it could not withstand the lateral loading required.

A dental technician would ‘block out’ the identified tooth and not include it in the custom-made device.

Expert's verdict on risk to your teeth and gums

All anti-snoring devices will aggravate your oral hygiene. 

However, a sleep-trained dentist would ensure BEFORE you had an MAD, that your hygiene and oral condition (teeth, gums and jaw-joints) were satisfactory before you began to use it.

Try to keep the device as clean as possible. Use your toothbrush and toothpaste on it each morning. Don’t use chlorine based denture cleaners on gumshield based devices – it makes them hard and brittle (unusable) rapidly. Instead, use a baby bottle sterilising fluid (follow the manufacturer’s instructions).

Brush and floss your teeth carefully and consider using a chlorhexidine mouthwash. If you spit blood when you clean your teeth consult a dentist/hygienist.

‘Boil-and-Bite’ devices will flex when worn and over time, this will procline (tilt forwards) your lower incisors and retrocline (tilt backwards) your upper incisors.

Certain custom-made anti-snoring devices are designed to avoid this tooth tilting movements.

Consult your sleep-trained dentist.

No. 5. Will an Anti-Snoring Device damage my jaw-joints?

Jaw pain is truly horrible and once you have a jaw pain problem it persists.

All types of mandibular advancement device (MAD) work by moving your lower jaw forwards, and the amount it does this to be effective, and not hurt too much, is specific to you.

Gumshields for snoring
Some gumshields for snoring are only adjustable in large increments, while others you have to fit the device – rather than the device actually fit you (again you may lose your money).
Custom-made MADs
Custom made, adjustable, prescription MADs really win when considering your jaw joint. In fact, it’s possible, with some of the custom made ones to start off wearing it with no (or very little) change in your jaw position.

While of course it won’t initially prevent snoring in this position, the dentist will gradually advance your jaw until you stop snoring over a matter of weeks or perhaps even longer (this is known as titration). This gives you, your device (and your jaw joint) time to get accustomed.

Which means you STOP SNORING!

And don’t permanently harm yourself. Yay!

Expert's verdict on jaw-joint risk
Your sleep-trained dentist will screen you for sleep apnoea, assess your teeth, gums and examine your jaw joints.

They will take X-rays and put things right beforehand if necessary. If it doesn’t look like its a good idea, they’ll suggest:

  • You DON’T have one,
  • Explain why,
  • And direct you to appropriate help.

If everything is OK, they’ll monitor the effect the MAD is having upon your teeth, gums, jaw joint and snoring.

If your jaw joint isn’t healthy before you start using an anti-snoring device then it may cause irreversible harm. (The exception is when a specialist sleep and jaw joint pain [Temporo-Mandibular Joint Dysfunction or TMD] dentist prescribes a device for BOTH issues.)

A sleep-trained dentist would know what to avoid and ensure you did not experience premature posterior contact (see call out box) that would damage your jaw-joint.

Premature posterior contact

This gets a bit technical.

A common problem particular to ‘gumshields’ occurs when the device is adjusted forwards known as ‘protrusion’ (you might do this in an attempt to increase the effect – and stop the snoring noise). The upper and lower parts of the device may then come into contact on just your back teeth.

This acts like a ‘bit’ for a horse – it gives you something to chew on. It ‘gags’ open the bite (keeps your jaws more open than they should be) and this uneven bite places enormous load on your jaw joints.

It would be even worse for your jaw joint, if this was on one side only, and as you close your mouth, your jaw has to ‘rotate’ around this ‘premature contact’. What the above means, is that your jaw has to move in unnatural ways.

This hurts. And if you use the device in this position (because you’re trying to appease your partner) you will irreversibly damage your jaw joint.

No. 6. Retention /  Fit of your Anti-Snoring Device (MAD)

How well your anti-snoring device fits, is known in dental terminology as ‘retention’.

But retention has two meanings in Dental Sleep Medicine (DSM is the term for MADs used to help with sleep-related breathing disorders, including snoring and OSA).

The first meaning is how well it keeps hold of your teeth, or to put it another way, how well it ‘clips on’ or stays in place. 

Most MAD designs rely upon its ability to ‘clip’ into place to then be able to hold your jaw forwards – and stop you snoring.

The second DSM interpretation of ‘retention’ relates to the MAD’s ability to hold open your airway, retain it in a forward position, and prevent you from snoring.

So, the right amount of retention (or fit) is essential for it to work.

Over-the-Counter ‘gumshield’ vendors make their money by relying on you being too lazy to seek a refund when it doesn’t work.

Read my review of ways they separate you from your money. ↗

Gumshields and retention
This is unavoidably technical. So, feel free to skip to my verdict.

Due to the necessary choice of thermo-plastic (it softens and becomes adaptable to you, when heated in boiling water) material used in ‘boil and bite’ devices, getting and keeping the right degree of retention, for the long-term is nigh on impossible.

The material ‘wants’ to go back to its original shape as it cools down, which is technically due to both the elastic memory and elastic recovery of the material. There’s more about the material used in the Lifespan or ‘Cost per wear’ section below.

Custom-made MADs
Custom-made dental devices for snoring are made for you (on prescription) from raw materials by a registered dental technician. While the materials used vary, they usually only become thermoplastic (soften when warmed up) when heated over 100 deg C.

On the other hand, ‘Customised fit‘ devices are the ‘Boil-and-Bite’ gumshield type of MAD (and I know you know water boils at 100 deg. C!).

Expert's verdict on retention of Anti-Snoring Devices
Boil-and-Bite gumshields for snoring as a general rule, cannot provide good retention.

Without good retention or ‘clip’ to your teeth, gumshields will not stop you snoring. End.

No. 7. Can I adjust the position of my Anti-Snoring Device (MAD)?

The ability to adjust the forward position of your jaw (adjust the protrusion to prevent snoring) impacts upon both comfort and how well it works.

The optimum position is unique to you. It has to be just far enough forward to prevent you from snoring, yet not so far forward, it hurts your jaw joints.

Fixed devices (sometimes called ‘monobloc’ devices) take an arbitrary approach to the forward position of your lower jaw. This primitive design (exhibited by both over-the-counter gumshields and some old tech custom-made ones) is likely to be less than ideal for comfort and effect.

Gumshields for snoring
For the MAD to prevent snoring it must prevent your mouth from falling open.

You should NOT need a chinstrap in addition to your anti-snoring device. If a chin straps is suggested then:

You need a different MAD.

If you’re trying to ensure you breathe through your nose and stop your mouth falling open, then read Chinstraps for snoring? Safe, Effective or Dangerous? [new window]. In my chin strap review, I examine if they have a role for snoring and obstructive sleep apnea (OSA).

If you can only breathe through your mouth and/or sometimes struggle to breathe through your nose, then consult your GP and seek an ENT assessment.

Custom-made, adjustable MADs
Custom-made, adjustable MADs are inherently adjustable (the clues in the name!)

The important thing to understand about adjustable MADs relates to their range of movement, and:

  • Whether this is sufficient
  • Whether it dictates a hard to tolerate initial position

The most modern custom-made adjustable MADs have between 8-10mm range of movement. If more is needed – you will most likely need a remake (more money).

Expert's verdict on ability to adjust the protrusion
Clearly, fixed or monobloc devices fail this test 🙂 A new anti-snoring device would need to be made if the jaw position was incorrect. Adjustable anti-snoring devices need to have sufficient range of motion to coincide with your jaw range of motion – or you must start in a forward jaw position, which may impact your ability to get along with the MAD initially.

No. 8. Life-span or ‘cost-per-wear’ of your Anti-Snoring Device

To ensure your purchase of an anti-snoring device (MAD) is not a waste of money or a false-economy, you have to consider:

  • Its outright price (don’t forget the clinical fees) and VAT (if its for snoring)
  • Its length of useful life

Amongst other things…

Gumshields for snoring
A material that softens in boiling water called ‘Ethylene Vinyl Acetate (EVA) or EVA’ is commonly used in gumshield type anti-snoring devices.

  • This material absorbs saliva from your mouth (and also any cleaning chemicals that may then leak back out into your mouth overnight – nice).
  • They are damaged if you grind your teeth because the material is soft and elastic.
  • Their typical lifespan is 6 months to 1.5 years before the EVA constructed gumshield becomes too smelly and unpleasant to use.
  • They also distort and place high lateral loads on your front teeth – making them very sore in the morning.
Custom-made Anti-Snoring Devices
Some early design variants of custom-made anti-snoring devices, are also made from EVA ‘blow down’ or vacuum formed blanks of CE marked material by a registered dental technician.

However, most are typically made from a type of denture acrylic (polymethylmethacrylate) or ‘PMMA’, and as such are stronger and less likely to absorb saliva than EVA materials. Some new variants are made from a type of ‘Nylon’ (polyamide) and are very strong in thin section (see Comfort and bulk above). This means they will last longer and therefore the ‘cost per wear’ may be reduced.

In the UK, it is also possible to obtain a custom-made anti-snoring device manufactured entirely from metal (known as ‘Chrome’ = Cobalt chrome wiki link: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cobalt-chrome new window ) While this type of manufacture may cost more (they are more time consuming to make) the material cross-section is extremely thin (fractions of a millimetre are possible) making the bulk in your mouth minimal (see comfort and bulk above). Additionally, the metal device does not absorb saliva or cleaning agents.

The downside is that any adjustment of ‘fit’ of metal devices may be problematic and over time the clasps (bits that wrap around your teeth to hold [retain – remember that?] the device in your mouth) may ‘relax’ and need adjusting.

Expert's verdict on lifespan of MADs
Broadly speaking its a sliding scale of cost versus lifespan.

The high-end devices using nylon or chrome are thinner and less bulky but are also difficult (if not impossible) to adjust. This does not mean to say its a problem, they just have to be perfectly made.

So, if its not – then it needs to be remade: Do not accept a poor fitting custom made anti-snoring device.

No. 9. Control of mouth opening

When using a mandibular advancement device (MAD) it is essential to prevent your mouth from falling open for effective snoring relief and to avoid making your airway narrower than it would be without a mandibular advancement device.

It should not be necessary to resort to a chin strap to control this. Yes, I’ve been over this point in Retention above, but…

Why does vertical opening matter?

The lower jaw rotates backwards as it opens which further narrows your airway and makes snoring worse (or if you have sleep apnoea / apnea may increase the severity and duration of apneaic episodes).

If your jaw is protruded with a mandibular advancement device (MAD) and your jaw falls open your airway may be narrower than without using an MAD.

See the three X-ray diagrams below, to understand why vertical opening with an MAD should be avoided. The red dots highlight how the airway increases / decreases with protrusion and vertical opening.

Images courtesy of Dr Ulrich Huebers DDS.

The diagram (below left) shows the size of the airway in your throat without a mandibular advancement device (MAD).

The diagram (below centre) shows the ideal situation. The mandibular advancement device advances the jaw and opens the airway in your throat.

The third diagram (below right) shows how the airway becomes narrower with both protrusion and vertical opening. Disaster.

rest position before a mandibular advancement device
Mandibular Advancement Device (MAD) with NO vertical opening in protrusion
mandibular advancement device
Gumshields and custom-made MADs
Both categories of MAD (Boil-and-Bite gumshield and custom-made MADs) can fail when examined against this important test metric.

  • Jaw advancement must increase as the mouth opens (protrusion must increase proportionally [to maintain the same effect] if vertical opening occurs).
  • Less protrusion correlates with:
    1. Less side-effects (including less risk of tooth movement and jaw pain)
    2. Increased tolerance and improved long-term compliance.

An interincisal opening (the distance measured between the upper and lower front teeth) of more than 5 mm has been associated with lower patient adherence (long-term use), perhaps as a result of discomfort.6

Expert's verdict on mouth opening
Minimal vertical opening (as in just sufficient to permit the lower jaw to advance without the upper and lower teeth hitting each other) should routinely be considered ideal. More than this may be necessary in selected cases where:

  • the tongue is large
  • the jaw is small

However, opening beyond 5mm (measured between the incisors) is uncomfortable, inhibits lip closure and detrimentally impacts long-term use. A design principle for MADs is control of vertical opening (note my previous comment about not needing a chin strap).

No. 10. Ability to move side-to-side (lateral movement)

It might seem obvious, but unless the MAD is worn, it cannot stop your snoring.

As such, it must be comfortable to use. Part of this comfort equation is the MAD not creating a ‘trapped’ sensation.

This may occur when the lower jaw is unable to move from side-to-side.

Gumshields and custom-made MADs
Some MADs (both custom-made and ‘Boil-and-Bite’) exhibit the capability to move laterally (side to side) while some do not. My viewpoint is that you should look for one that does permit movement.
Expert's verdict on lateral movement
If you grind your teeth (brux) then this will significantly impact the life-expectancy of your MAD. In fact, you may work harden metal components necessitating their earlier replacement, than would otherwise be expected.

Finally, while it is perhaps a contentious area, if you routinely ‘brux’, then an anti-snoring device that does not permit side-to-side (lateral) movement may actually disrupt your sleep. One theory suggests that this is because your attempts to move are hindered.

The opposing theory suggests you will no longer brux when your apnea is resolved. The jury is out.

No. 11. Does the Anti-Snoring Device mechanism invade your tongue-space?

Ever had a filling or a crown? You may recall how you were very conscious of it. You probably explored it with your tongue and it felt alien. Every anti-snoring device will feel huge in your mouth when you start to use it.

Consequently, less is more!

 

Less physical presence in your mouth, squashing your tongue, enhances your ability to initially accept it and keep using it – and stop snoring…

The concept behind an MAD is to advance the jaw, and in turn, move the tongue forwards and away from the back of your throat.

This increases your airway dimensions and improves tissue tone, which stops you snoring.

So, when an MAD is too bulky, it squashes your tongue. Which is self-defeating.

Gumshields and tongue space
Typically, gumshields are bulky and squash your tongue. They may even have rough or sharp edges which may cause tongue ulcers.

Technically, this may occur with ‘gumshields’ at the junction between two materials, typically with devices that have a hard-outer shell and a softer thermoplastic liner, or when they are crudely ‘adjusted’ with home equipment i.e. scissors!

Prescription, custom-made MADs

Construction

Some primitive custom MADs are bulky and invade tongue space. Materials technology is continually improving, and thinner cross-section devices are now appearing on the market using laser sintered polyamide (a type of nylon).

While traditionally manufactured metal (known as ‘chrome’) devices are available. These may be expensive to make (as they are labour intensive) and may necessitate plastic and metal combined devices, which builds in failure points (because dissimilar materials exhibit different mechanical properties).

Placement of the adjustment mechanism

The placement of adjustment mechanisms in the tongue space is uncomfortable and counter-productive (see concept note above in introduction to this point). Some early custom MADs used orthodontic screw mechanisms in the palate or inside the lower jaw (lingually).

A sleep-trained dentist will guide you when you choose. To get informed for that conversation download our free, evidence-based How to Choose a Mouthpiece Guide. new window

Expert’s verdict on tongue space invasion
If you can’t wear your MAD, then its pointless having it. Consequently, comfort has to be a pivotal deciding factor when selecting one.

Anything placed where your tongue can contact it, is a negative. Remember less is more, when it comes to MAD design.

No. 12. Easy to Keep Clean (Extend useful life, hygiene)

Consult your dentist and the MAD manufacturer’s instructions on how to clean your MAD.

I would suggest that broadly speaking you should (every time you remove it in the morning) use a toothbrush and toothpaste on the device before/after cleaning your teeth. Floss if you have the enthusiasm and discipline… and consider using a chlorhexidine mouthwash too.

Having worked in this industry for longer than I care to remember, I know that MADs must be:

  • Easy to keep clean
  • Not absorb cleaning fluid or saliva
  • Ideally not have intricate mechanisms to retain food and bacteria
  • Be entirely made of one material

Bacterial biofilm (a slimy film of infectious microbes) will form on the device. It’s important to pay extra attention to your oral hygiene (and keep the MAD clean with a toothbrush immediately you remove it in the morning).

Gumshields for snoring
These materials absorb saliva (and cleaning fluids) so bacteria are drawn into the material itself – not just on the surface. Ewww.
Prescription, Custom MADs
The use of materials with better properties, more suited to long-term use in your mouth, should have less detrimental impact. You will of course need to keep them clean and remove the biofilm – and keep your teeth and gums really clean.

See a dental hygienist if you need assistance keeping on top of this. Its an investment.

Expert’s verdict
Prescription, custom-made MADs utilise materials that are better-suited to long-term use. They are inherently easier to clean and keep clean. This is vital when you consider the number of people who have gum disease (gingivitis) whose condition would be aggravated by an MAD, perhaps to such an extent that they risked losing a tooth.

Top Tip

If you are lucky enough to have a marble bathroom, make sure that the MAD cleaning fluid does NOT splash out (powder or granule type cleaning products are commonly a type of acid that permanently damages marble). Ideally, clean your MAD elsewhere! (Voice of experience! Customer reported the above to me when I ran Zacher Sleep Appliances).

No. 13. Side-effects of Anti-Snoring Devices (Mandibular Advancement Devices)

There’s always a down-side!

Or in ‘English’:

“You don’t get nowt for nowt”

side-effect
The most common side-effect from Anti-Snoring Devices (MADs)
The most common initial side-effect from using anti-snoring devices is related to saliva. Some people find they dribble while wearing the device during the first few weeks of use. Others may find they have a dry mouth.
The next most common side-effect is jaw ache
This is normally transient and may arise during the ‘titration’ period (where the device is adjusted to gradually advance your lower jaw and stop you snoring).

If this occurs, the correct advice is to speak with your dental clinician. It normally resolves itself but do not suffer in silence.

Longer term, changes in the position of your teeth may occur
This is due to the weight of your lower jaw (think gravity) and the muscles attached to it combining to attempt return of your jaw to its normal position. These forces are all transferred to your teeth and their roots.

This is why even the most wonderful anti-snoring devices are NOT suitable for children – because they would act like an orthodontic device and move their teeth in uncontrolled ways (exceptionally an orthodontist may prescribe an anti-snoring device for certain children with particular needs).

Expert's verdict on side-effects
It is really important to keep things in perspective: Not snoring, breathing and sleeping at the same time or perhaps minor tooth movement?

However, as I have highlighted throughout this review all anti-snoring devices have side-effects.

A sleep-trained dentist would screen you for sleep apnoea, help you stop snoring and minimise (and if necessary correct) any side-effects. They also carry professional indemnity insurance and use prescription anti-snoring devices made to quality standards by registered dental technicians.

FREE BONUS

Download our free, NHS England’s Information Standard accredited, evidence-based, expert-written and jargon-decoded Guide

(that’s a mouthful!):

> How to Choose a ‘Mouthpiece’ to Stop Snoring

You’ll learn about your options and be able to make more informed choices.

No registration is required.

They’re also free on Google Play:

google play

If you snore and self-help isn’t cutting it then don’t self-diagnose. Get signposted to the most appropriate professional to help you. Its free, evidence-based and a simple way to find out if snoring is actually a symptom of sleep apnoea.

NHS England's Information Standard UK
top-selling anti-snoring devices

Summary

This review has examined the best anti-snoring devices, both Over-the-Counter and custom-made, against my top 13 criteria, to help you choose an anti-snoring device that works, and is safe and effective.

My final verdict is that while a ‘boil-and-bite’ gumshield may prevent snoring for a short while (if you fit the gadget) they are ultimately a false economy and won’t work for long (if at all).

Longer-term, if you were to persevere with a ‘gumshield’ for snoring, it would:

  • Create unpleasant and sometimes permanent, unmanaged dental side-effects
  • Potentially irreversibly damage your jaw-joints
  • And it delays potential OSA diagnosis and effective treatment

In conclusion, clinical research3 has established that ‘boil-and-bite’ gumshields are not valid as either a trial or treatment device.

But this is not a definitive guide to OTC anti-snoring device manufacturers’ claims. This is.

 

The real question

The real question is:

Why do you snore?

My advice is to get signposted to the most appropriate professional, get screened for sleep apnoea and learn why you snore and how to stop.

Here’s the next step:

Found this review useful?

Write a review below, and let me know.

Reviews

default image

Really helpful when I was worried about my OH’s snoring. Gave me info on what to worry about. Next stop the GP.

Mrs P Really interesting stuff! May 24, 2018


default gravatar

If you are looking for impartial advice about snoring from an expert in the field, the highly respected Adrian Zacher should be your go to. We applaud Adrian’s work, to raise awareness about the health implications of snoring, and the importance of custom-made devices for long-term success.

Lucie Ash Director Somnowell How to choose the best anti-snoring device September 7, 2018

Found this useful?

Let others know what you think.

1 - 5 out of 5, where 5/5 is the best and 1/5 is the worst


Expert reviews and ‘How-to’ Guides related to Anti-Snoring Devices:

Here are some more high quality reviews about anti-snoring devices, snoring and sleep apnoea / apnea products, cures and aids!

Glossary

Anti-Snoring Device – generally considered a product worn in your mouth to stop you snoring.

Boil-and-Bite – a type of gumshield for snoring that may be adapted to you by softening the material in boiling water. See OTC below.

Custom-made – a bespoke device made exclusively for you by a registered dental technician, working to prescription, using CE marked materials. In Europe working to the Medical Devices Directive  administered in the UK by the Medicines and Healthcare Products Regulatory Authority (MHRA).

DSM Dental Sleep Medicine – the management of sleep-related breathing disorders using dental devices.

Gumshield for snoring – see ‘Boil-and-Bite’ above.

Information Standard – NHS England’s Information Standard. Organisations that join The Information Standard are showing their commitment to producing good quality, evidence-based health and care information.

MAD Mandibular Advancement Device – Jaw advancing device, worn at night while asleep to hold forward the lower jaw to stop snoring and prevent obstructive sleep apnoea / apnea.

MAS Mandibular Advancement Splint – See ‘MAD’.

MRD Mandibular Repositioning Device – See ‘MAD’.

OSA Obstructive Sleep Apnoea – (also spelt apnea) When an individual is unable to sleep and breathe at the same time. Visually, a repetitive pattern of breathing interruptions (apnoeas) occurring while the individual sleeps, due to a physical obstruction in the airway.

OTC – Over-the-Counter product sold over the pharmacy counter or on-line without prescription, medical or dental assessment and without a review of medical/dental history.

Signposting – Is the medical term for directing people to the most appropriate professional to help them based upon their answers to some high-level questions.

Sleep-trained Dentist – A dentist that has undergone special interest training in sleep. As such they are able to obtain professional indemnity insurance.

TMD – Temporo-Mandibular Joint Dysfunction. Jaw-ache or pain, due to abnormal or impaired movement.

References

  1. Snoring cures success ‘exaggerated’ http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/health/1701735.stm new window [accessed 16th Oct 2016]
  2. Stradling, J. and Dookun, R. 2009, Snoring and the role of the GDP: British Society of Dental Sleep Medicine (BSDSM) pre-treatment screening protocol, British Dental Journal, 206, 307 – 312. Available here: http://www.nature.com/bdj/journal/v206/n6/abs/sj.bdj.2009.214.html new window [accessed 12 April 2017]
  3. Vanderveken OM, Devolder A, Marklund M, et al, 2008. Comparison of a custom-made and a thermoplastic oral appliance for the treatment of mild sleep apnea. Am J Respir Crit Care Med; 178: 197–202. Available here: http://www.atsjournals.org/doi/abs/10.1164/rccm.200701-114OC#.V9ukcFT_rio new window [accessed 12 April 2017]
  4. Ready-Made Versus Custom-Made Mandibular Repositioning Devices in Sleep Apnea: A Randomized Clinical Trial, Johal A, Haria P, Manek S, Joury E, Riha R. Ready-Made Versus Custom-Made Mandibular Repositioning Devices in Sleep Apnea: A Randomized Clinical Trial. Journal of Clinical Sleep Medicine : JCSM : Official Publication of the American Academy of Sleep Medicine. 2017;13(2):175-182. doi:10.5664/jcsm.6440. Available here: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC5263072/ new window [accessed 18th June 2018]
  5. A crossover randomised controlled trial of oral mandibular advancement devices for obstructive sleep apnoea-hypopnoea (TOMADO). Quinnell TG, Bennett M, Jordan J, Clutterbuck-James AL, Davies MG, Smith IE, Oscroft N, Pittman MA, Cameron M, Chadwick R, Morrell MJ, Glover MJ, Fox-Rushby JA, Sharples LD. Thorax. 2014 Oct; 69(10):938-45. Available here: http://thorax.bmj.com/content/68/Suppl_3/A4.1  new window [accessed 18th June 2018]
  6. Pitsis AJ, Darendeliler MA, Gotsopoulos H, et al: Effect of vertical dimension on efficacy of oral appliance therapy in obstructive sleep apnea. Am J Respir Crit Care Med 166:860, 2002. Available here: https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/12231498  new window [accessed 18th June 2018]

Created by Adrian Zacher | Page last updated 24th May 2019

Guidelines for the Medical Profession? Oral Appliances for Snoring/OSA

Guidelines for the Medical Profession? Oral Appliances for Snoring/OSA

by | Feb 1, 2012 | diagnosis, Healthcare Professional, Medical, Sleep-Related Breathing Disorders, undiagnosed | 1 comment

UK Guideline development

This past decade has seen further clarity develop around the provision of mandibular repositioning devices (oral appliances for snoring and sleep apnoea).

In 2012, the British Society of Dental Sleep Medicine’s (BSDSM) screening protocol (first published in 2009) [i] was elevated to ‘authoritative guidelines’ by Dr Rob Jagger when reviewing a paper by Jauhar et al examining the Kushida Index in the British Dental Journal [ii]

The same year saw the BSDSM protocol further endorsed by the Association of Respiratory Technology and Physiology in their Standards of Care position statement [iii]. This was updated in 2018 to version 4. [iv].

I’m a sleep-industry insider with a quarter of century of sleep medicine experience.

Adrian Zacher MBA

Snoring & Sleep Apnoea Care Navigator

Californian Dental Association

The Californian Dental Association (CDA) [v] determined in 2012 that it is appropriate for dentists to screen patients for the signs and symptoms of sleep disordered breathing (SDB) and work with physicians to diagnose and treat SDB.

The CDA also stated that SDB is a medical condition and its diagnosis is outside the scope of the practice of dentistry.

This is all excellent progress towards appropriate patient assessment, screening and where appropriate provision of an MRD by a dentist.

 

However, two further issues remain:

1 Self diagnosis and fitting of Over-The-Counter ‘Boil & Bite’ devices (people need help and a proper assessment for OSA to determine the most appropriate therapy – not exploiting and delaying patients from effective treatment)

2 How to discourage the medical profession from supplying or by lack of guidance endorsing, use of ‘Boil & Bite’ devices.

Summary

A multi-disciplinary, holistic view of the patient that breaks down the current silo approach to patient care surely makes ethical and financial sense.

Perhaps raising awareness that effective treatment options for OSA exist and consensus development of guidelines that dentistry is not within the purview of a physician is required?

Let’s not even talk about professional indemnity…!

Related reviews

References and related Guidelines

Professor Stradling and Mr Grant Bates proposed GP Guidelines 'Management of sleep apnoea and snoring, suggested guidelines for General Practitioners and other interested medical professionals'. I would note that this document was created prior to the BSDSM Pre-treatment Screening Protocol.

[i] British Society of Dental Sleep Medicine, Pre-treatment screening protocol. British Dental Journal, 2009  http://www.nature.com/bdj/journal/v206/n6/abs/sj.bdj.2009.214.html new-window [accessed 1 February 2012]
[ii] Jauhar et al (2012) The Kushida Index as a screening tool for obstructive sleep apnoea-hypopnoea syndrome, http://www.nature.com/bdj/journal/v212/n1/full/sj.bdj.2012.2.html new-window [accessed 1 February 2012].
[iii] Association of Respiratory Technology and Physiology (2012) ARTP Standards of Care for Sleep Apnoea Services (Mandibular Repositioning Devices) http://www.artp.org.uk/en/sleep/sleep-standards/index.cfm new-window [accessed 1 February 2012]
[iv] ARTP standards of care for mandibular repositioning devices http://www.artp.org.uk/en/sleep/sleep-standards/sleep-documents.cfm/sleep-standards-iods new-window [accessed 23 Oct 2018]
[v] California Dental Association (2012) http://www.cda.org/Portals/0/journal/journal_022012.pdf? new-window [accessed 6th Mar 2013]

Created by Adrian Zacher. Last updated 21st May 2019.